County Planning Commission mixed on wind turbines

 

With the rising cost of electricity, many homeowners are seeking ways to generate power on their property. Could wind turbines be part of the answer for Albemarle County residents?

That was the basic question explored in a work session held by the County Planning Commission on May 13, 2008. Mark Graham, the Director of Community Development, briefed the Commission on how wind power works, and explained that the structures are currently not permitted under existing zoning. He also assessed the viability for a commercial wind farm, and the results aren’t promising.

Podcast produced by Charlottesville Tomorrow * Player by Odeo

Listen using player above or download the podcast: Download 20080513-APC-Turbines.mp3

To generate enough electricity to be commercially successful, an operator needs sustained winds, close access to the national power grid and transmission lines, as well as roads that can transport very heavy components. A wind resource map created by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) shows only a handful of spots in Albemarle County, such as Bucks Elbow, where a commercial site might work. However, Graham suggested the site’s proximity to Shenandoah National Park would likely prevent any application from being permitted by the State Corporation Commission.

An example of a small wind turbine

However, the bulk of the work session dealt with whether the County zoning ordinances should be amended to allow small wind turbines for residential or agricultural use. To be effective in generating a current, a turbine must be tall enough to catch sustained winds. The taller the tower, the more power is generated. Turbines also need enough clearance to avoid causing turbulence in surrounding structures.  Graham said the bottom of the rotor needs to be at least thirty foot above rooftops or landscaping. 

“Right now under the zoning ordinance with residential properties, the maximum height for structures is 35 feet,” Graham said. He also pointed to a chart that showed how taller towers can greatly maximize the voltage generated, but said the smaller ones could power well pumps. 

Graham said mountainsides and hilltops are the best locations for turbines in Albemarle County, but if they are permitted, a land-owner would need to clear-cut several acres around the turbines in order to provide for enough space for the wind patterns to be sustained.  That would conflict the County’s comprehensive plan, which calls for protecting tree cover in rural areas.

However, Graham said the technology is changing, particularly in European countries that are rapidly developing wind power. Firms are experimenting with using different shapes to capture wind in urban environments, and also to minimize noise and wildlife issues. Graham also suggested wireless providers might also develop wind turbines as way of getting taller cell towers through co-location, though the technology for this does not currently exist.

Commissioner Tom Loach (White Hall) asked Graham if anyone had approached the County about installing a turbine. Graham said no one had yet officially sought a permit, but he was aware of a couple of interested parties in the County. He said investigating those is a very low priority for his department, but the Board had directed staff to do this preliminary investigation.

Commissioner Marcia Joseph (At-Large) said she would be interested in pursuing a way to allow for small wind turbines. Graham suggested one course of action would be to allow them as an accessory to a building, which could be regulated with a special use permit.

This wind resource map from the U.S. Department of Energy shows that Albemarle County is "wind poor"

Loach said given community opposition to cell phone towers that are only seven to ten feet taller than surrounding trees, he could not see a future for small wind turbines. Loach said residential structures are capped at 35 feet in the County, and questioned what wind turbines twice that height would look like.

Joseph said she did not want to preclude a farmer from constructing one in a field, and that she wanted staff to work on an ordinance change.  She said the country needs to be looking at other energy resources, and said she was concerned that land owners can’t currently even consider putting up a wind turbine. Chairman Calvin Morris (Rivanna) agreed that residential wind turbines should be allowed in specific cases.

Commissioner Linda Porterfield (Scottsville) was another voice against pursuing the ordinance change, given the current work load of planning staff. Instead, the County should encourage residents and businesses to invest in solar technology. Commissioner Eric Strucko (Samuel Miller) said because of Albemarle’s “wind-poor” status, other options should be explored, but said a way should be found to allow small-scale ventures. Commissioner Bill Edgerton (Jack Jouett) agreed that owners of large tracts of land should be able to experiment, given rapid changes in technology.

Commissioner Jon Cannon (Rio) said he thought the permitting process would be just as controversial as the one for cell towers, but that the County should take a deeper look. He wanted staff to find out more about the feasibility of turbines before making a commitment.

Sean Tubbs

Comments

[Waldo Jaquith]

FWIW, while Albemarle is "wind-poor" in comparison to other parts of the world (and even the state), there are sites in the Southwest Mountains -- where I live -- and all along the western edge of the county along the Blue Ridge that are relatively good. I don't know whether it would be a viable business concept to install a turbine, I'd like very much to install one on my own property.

JMU actually loans out anemometers through their small wind program, available to anybody who wants to know how the wind is at on their own property. They studied wind up on Bucks Elbow, the only site they've studied in Albemarle, and found an average wind speed of 13.86 mph, just about always from the WNW. Skystream recommends a 12mph average wind speed to make a turbine a sensible thing to own.

So if Buck's Elbow is any metric, there's at least a market for small wind in Albemarle. Wind farms, I expect, will be a lot more logical out in Highland or, better still, in the Chesapeake Bay.

[Alex van der Beek]

Many people around the world seem to have something against wind turbines, that's why we've started a couple of years ago to develop an alternative.

We start to produce natural looking trees and plants from recycled plastics, these trees and plants are fitted with NANO-leaves combining the latest nano technologies; photovoltaic, thermovoltaic and piezevoltaic, thus converting 3 free available energies resources like SUN, WIND & THERMAL into electricity, all year around 24/7.

Besides the aesthetic values of natural looking vegetation, they do not face huge opposition from local planning commissions.
Our trees are 70% more effective than any other known system, durable, easy to install and much cheaper as wind turbines. Solar Botanics is a solution for many people, villages, cities and places of natural beauty.
It took trees millions of years to design the perfect energy harvesting system, we only have tweaked it a little, so we can enjoy all the benefits that nature has to offer.

You can in the near future locally produce and assemble our Solar Botanic Trees and plants, creating jobs and a peaceful landscape while harvesting power.
Currently we are busy developing our website and testing our structures, molding and designing different tree and plant species.

For more information please contact us. We welcome your feedback,

[Dale Dudley]

I saw the wind turbine at a business in OBX. He said that he completely powered a Landscape company with his. I am interested in installing one at a home I am building in Earlysville, 21 acres in Advanced Mills Farms. I would be interested in being an experiment for the county. The wind seems to blow harder and more frequently in this location. I looked into solar but there does not seem to be the return on investment and the panels needed to generate the same power seem to be huge and more unsightly. Please respond to my comments. 434-996-5200